The Commission is comprised of twenty-two Commissioners. The various Commissioners are appointed as designated in Rule 21 by separate appointing authorities including the Chief Justice of the Hawai`i Supreme Court, the Hawai`i State Bar Association, the Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Service Providers, the Hawai`i Justice Foundation, the Williams S. Richardson School of Law, the Hawai`i Paralegal Association, the Governor, the Attorney General, the Senate President, and the Speaker of the House. The Commissioners are listed as follows:
| Name | Appointed By | Term Ends | |
| 1. | Hon. Joseph E. Cardoza (ret.) (Chair) | Chief Justice | 12/31/23 |
| 2. | Hon. Brian Costa | Chief Justice | 12/31/24 |
| 3. | Hon. Todd W. Eddins | Chief Justice | 12/31/24 |
| 4. | — | Chief Justice | 12/31/24 |
| 5. | Hon. Michael K. Soong | Chief Justice | 12/31/24 |
| 6. | Christine Daleiden | Hawai`i State Bar Association | 12/31/23 |
| 7. | Derek R. Kobayashi (Vice-Chair) | Hawai`i State Bar Association | 12/31/25 |
| 8. | Carol K. Muranaka | Hawai`i State Bar Association | 12/31/23 |
| 9. | Jacky Mena | Hawai`i State Bar Association | 12/31/25 |
| 10. | Rachel Figueroa (Volunteer Legal Services of Hawai`i) | Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Services Providers | 12/31/25 |
| 11. | Angela Lovitt (Legal Aid Society of Hawai`i) |
Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Services Providers | 12/31/24 |
| 12. | Erin Sugita (Domestic Violence Action Center) |
Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Services Providers | 12/31/25 |
| 13. | Makalika Naholowa`a (Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation) |
Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Services Providers | 12/31/25 |
| 14. | Heather Lusk (Non-attorney public representative) | Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Services Providers in consultation with Chief Justice | 12/31/24 |
| 15. | Rona Fukumoto (Non-attorney public representative) | Hawai`i Consortium of Legal Services Providers in consultation with Chief Justice | 12/31/23 |
| 16. | Mihoko Ito | Hawaii Justice Foundation | 12/31/22 |
| 17. | Dean Aviam Soifer | William S. Richardson School of Law |
12/31/22 |
| 18. | Kalen Sato | Hawai`i Paralegal Association | 12/31/25 |
| 19. | — | Governor | n/a |
| 20. | — | Attorney General | n/a |
| 21. | Hon. Gilbert Keith-Agaran | Senate President | n/a |
| 22. | Hon. Della Au Belatti | House Speaker | n/a |